Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Letter: Welcoming Home Our Fay Elementary Student and Demanding Accountability for Family Separations and Educational Continuity

This letter was sent on Tuesday, November 17 to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, and the Office of Refugee Resettlement. If you have questions, contact James Canning at 313-580-2845 or jcanning@sandi.net

2026.11.17_FINAL_Return_ChangeStillNeeded_ORR_DHS.pdf 

November 17, 2026

The Honorable Markwayne Mullin
Secretary of Homeland Security
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
245 Murray Lane S.W.
Washington, D.C. 20528

The Honorable Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.
Secretary of Health and Human Services
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
200 Independence Avenue, S.W.
Washington, D.C. 20201

Re: Welcoming Home Our Fay Elementary Student and Demanding Accountability for Family Separations and Educational Continuity

Dear Secretary Mullin and Secretary Kennedy,

We are deeply relieved and grateful that the eight-year-old Haitian student from San Diego Unified’s Fay Elementary—who was recently detained by your agencies—has been reunited with his uncle and is being welcomed back to his third-grade classroom. While all of San Diego celebrates his safe return, our immediate focus is on supporting the emotional healing of this young boy, his family, and the Fay Elementary community.

However, his safe return does not mean the trauma caused to the student, his family, or his school community has ended. Family separation inflicts lasting psychological harm and must be stopped. Our district is pouring our hearts, expertise, and resources into those affected by this situation with crisis counseling and wraparound support to help our students and staff heal from the fear and disruption your policies created.

This child’s detention was the direct result of the administration’s decision to eliminate Temporary Protected Status (TPS) protections earlier this year—a policy choice that has stripped stability from vulnerable families who have built their lives in our communities.

A single reunification does not fix a broken, harmful system. To ensure no other child is torn from their loved ones and their classroom, we again call on the administration to restore TPS, end family separations, and halt ICE enforcement at or near schools and sensitive locations.

Furthermore, we reiterate our original demands that the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) and the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) immediately reform their policies and procedures affecting school-aged children who enter government custody or placement, including never placing a child in restraints or handcuffs. Specifically, we demand your agencies:

  • Prioritize placement decisions that keep children as close as possible to their home schools and communities.
  • Coordinate directly with local school districts before relocation decisions are finalized so educational impacts can be assessed.
  • Develop formal protocols between HHS, ORR, state agencies, and school districts to ensure uninterrupted access to education.
  • Place children with approved relatives, foster families, or temporary care providers located within the attendance area of their existing schools whenever feasible.
  • Establish transportation and enrollment supports that allow children to remain connected to their school community even during temporary placements.
  • Track and publicly report educational outcomes for children affected by federal placement and immigration-related custody decisions.

Every child deserves stability, dignity, and access to education, regardless of immigration status or family circumstances. Federal agencies have both a moral and institutional obligation to work collaboratively with school districts to keep families together and ensure educational continuity is never sacrificed to immigration enforcement.

We expect your departments to review these demands immediately and engage with school districts, child welfare experts, educators, and community leaders to implement child-centered solutions that prevent this trauma from ever happening again.

Sincerely,

Fabi Bagula, Ph.D., Superintendent, San Diego Unified School District

Richard Barrera, Board President, San Diego Unified School District

Sabrina Bazzo, Board Vice President, San Diego Unified School District

Sharon Whitehurst-Payne, Ph.D., Board Trustee, San Diego Unified School District

Shana Hazan, Board Trustee, San Diego Unified School District

Cody Petterson, Board Trustee, San Diego Unified School District

Sean Elo-Rivera, Councilmember, City of San Diego

Monique Barrett, President, San Diego Education Association

Miguel Arellano, President, California School Employees Association Chapter 759 Paraeducators

Dawn Basques, President, California School Employees Association Chapter 788 Office-Technical and Business Services

Jeffrey Thomas, President, Administrators Association of San Diego

Edward Lovato Jr., President, California School Employees Association Chapter 724 Operations-Support Services

Dr. Akilah Weber Pierson, Senator, California State Senate District 39

Dr. LaShae Sharp-Collins, Assemblymember, California State Assembly District 79

###

Uploaded Image

James Canning (He/Him)
Executive Director
Strategic Communications & Information
San Diego Unified School District

Mobile: 313-580-2845
Office: 619-725-5578
Email: Jcanning@sandi.net

4100 Normal Street
San Diego, CA 92103

www.sandiegounified.org

    




San Diego Unified School District would like to continue connecting with you via email. If you prefer to be removed from our list and stop receiving all email messages distributed through SchoolMessenger, follow this link and confirm: Unsubscribe. Please note that if you unsubscribe, you will no longer receive emails from your child’s school.